Elsevier

Water Research

Volume 153, 15 April 2019, Pages 335-348
Water Research

Review
Disinfectant residual stability leading to disinfectant decay and by-product formation in drinking water distribution systems: A systematic review

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2019.01.020Get rights and content

Highlights

  • Factors intricately affect disinfectant decay and disinfection byproducts formation.

  • Influencing factors may lead to positive feedback loops on disinfectant stability.

  • Microbial activity is the most influencing factor among all other factors.

  • Pipe material is a major factor (in)directly affecting disinfectant stability.

  • Proposal for predicting disinfectant residual stability by a Bayesian Network model.

Abstract

Secondary disinfectants, such as chlorine and chloramine, have been widely applied to minimise microbial risks in drinking water during distribution. Key challenges have included the maintenance of stable concentrations of disinfectant residuals and the control of disinfection by-products that may form as a consequence of residual decay processes. Many factors may influence disinfectant residual stability and the consequential formation of by-products. Thus predictions of disinfectant stability and by-product formation are multifactorial problems, complete with numerous complications of parameter co-dependence and feedback amplification of some key parameters. The aim of this review was to derive an understanding of how disinfectant residual stability in drinking water distribution systems is impacted by various influencing factors such as water quality and operational parameters. Factors known to influence disinfectant stability and by-product formation were critically reviewed. A systematic review method was applied to identify 1809 journal articles published in the two decades from January 1998 to December 2017. From the initial screening, 161 papers were selected for detailed assessment. Important factors were identified to include temperature, water age, piping material, corrosion products, pH, hydraulic condition, disinfectant residual type and dosage and microbial activity. Microbial activity is a particularly complex parameter on which to base predictions since many factors are known to influence the degree and nature of such activity. These include temperature, water age, piping material, corrosion products, nutrients, natural organic matter, hydraulic condition and disinfectant residual type and dosage. Disinfectant types and dosages were found to be among the most important factors. Many knowledge gaps and research needs still remain, including the need for a more complete understanding of the factors that influence the production of nitrogenous disinfection by-products.

Introduction

Drinking water utilities invest considerable resources in producing safe drinking water. Most of this effort and much of the accompanying water quality monitoring occur at drinking water treatment plants. However, after exiting a water treatment plant and before delivery to a customer's tap, there are numerous opportunities for water quality changes. These include potential reactions with disinfection residuals and concurrent formation of disinfection by-products (DBPs), presenting additional public health risks.

Physical components of drinking water distribution systems (DWDS) include treated water storage reservoirs, pipes and pumping stations. Each of these components may vary considerably in terms of water distribution capacity, manufactured materials and age or condition. The characteristics of a distribution system and the conditions under which it is operated may have important impacts on the potential for post-treatment changes in water quality. Distribution distances can be relatively short or can be in excess of 100 km with a retention time commonly varying between 1 and 7 days (AWWA, 2002; Blokker et al., 2016). Highly variable population densities and flow rates lead to corresponding variabilities in the relationship between distribution distance and time. For example, delivering water 50 km requires a retention time of 12–24 h in Beijing while in Australian cities such as Sydney and Brisbane (can be up to 20 days), 3–5 days is not unusual. Prolonged water age is also influenced by the need for water storage tanks to ensure adequate availability for firefighting and other emergencies (Australian Government, 2014; AWWA, 2002).

A free chlorine residual has been used as a disinfectant in DWDS in many countries for much of the 20th Century due to its high performance in disinfection and relatively low cost (McGuire, 2006). However, some limitations with using such a reactive chemical species as a distribution residual have been observed to include rapid decay (in some systems) and associated production of DBPs, such as trihalomethanes (THMs), haloacetic acids (HAAs) and other halogenated DBPs (Gagnon et al., 2006). Consequently, many drinking water utilities have switched to alternative disinfectant residuals, including chloramine and, to a much lesser extent, chlorine dioxide (Gagnon et al., 2006; NHMRC and NRMMC, 2011).

While chloramine is well-known to produce reduced chlorinated DBPs (Cl-DBPs), compared to free chlorine, the introduction of ammonia and chlorinated amines amplifies the risk of producing nitrogenous DBPs (N-DBPs) under certain conditions. This is of concern since some N-DBPs may present greater risks to public health, including carcinogenicity, compared to non-nitrogenous DBPs (Richardson et al., 2007). Disinfectant residual decay and DBP production may be a result of biofilms which are known to occur in treated water distribution systems contributing bacterial sources and organic matter (Lemus Pérez and Rodríguez Susa, 2017; Wang et al., 2013a). Although chloramine is more persistent than chlorine in the absence of nitrifying conditions, it decomposes more rapidly once nitrification occurs in distribution systems (Sathasivan et al., 2008). Bacteria present in distribution system biofilms release soluble microbial products (SMP), especially proteins which accelerate chloramine decay and DBP formation (Herath et al. 2015, 2018; Liu et al., 2014). Re-chlor(am)ination is commonly practised to maintain disinfectant levels in distribution systems (Bal Krishna et al. 2014, 2016) but may also lead to greater N-DBP production (Zeng and Mitch, 2016). Due to security concerns, many of these re-chlor(am)ination facilities have now switched from chlorine gas to safer disinfectants, such as sodium hypochlorite (Copeland and Cody, 2007).

The relationships between distribution system conditions and microbial activity within networks have been investigated by many researchers (Lehtola et al., 2006; Liu et al., 2017c; Ndiongue et al., 2005; Simoes et al., 2006; Tsvetanova and Dimitrov, 2012). Similarly, the relationships between distribution system conditions and chemical changes, such as disinfectant residual decay and DBP formation, have been widely reported (Kim et al., 2014; Lee et al., 2007; Liu et al., 2012; Simard et al., 2011; Zhang et al., 2017a). However, microbial and chemical changes are intricately related as has been shown by research focused on the impact of nitrification processes on disinfection residuals (Krishna et al., 2013; Lemus Pérez and Rodríguez Susa, 2017; Sathasivan et al., 2008; Wang et al., 2012; Zeng and Mitch, 2016). In addition to the interaction between microbial growth and disinfectant stability, microbial and chemical changes in disinfectant stability have similar influencing factors, such as water qualities and operating conditions. Therefore, varying these influencing factors would affect microbial growth and chemical reactions of disinfectants, while the change in microbial activities would further impact disinfectant stability. Few studies have sought to comprehensively examine both types of activities simultaneously, in order to provide a more complete understanding of the inter-relationships. The mathematical model developed by Abokifa et al. (2016) showed the importance of integrating bacterial growth dynamics models with predictive DBP formation models. Therefore, a systematic review is presented here to assess the current state of knowledge regarding disinfectant residual stability, as influenced by microbial activity as well as other independent factors in DWDS. The objective was to draw reasonable conclusions across studies that have focused on either one or the other sub-research topic. The review concludes with the identification of research gaps, which must be filled in order to provide a more complete understanding of the overall changes in water quality that may occur between drinking water treatment and delivery of that water to customer's taps.

Section snippets

Methods

A systematic quantitative literature review was performed based on the method described by Pickering and Byrne (2014) and the protocol developed by the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) (Fig. 1) (Moher et al., 2009). Research papers were searched on Web of Science (Clarivate Analytics, 2017) using an advanced topic search using keywords “drinking water OR potable water” AND “distribution system* OR reticulation system*” AND “chemical OR microbial OR

Results

The keyword search initially returned a list of 1809 articles. After manually screening, 234 articles were identified as potentially fulfilling criteria mentioned in Section 2, and 161 papers were then selected in this review after assessing full text.

Disinfectant residual stability including disinfectant decay and DBP production in DWDS are related to the chemical, microbiological and physical characteristics of water, and to the pipe materials in contact with water flow (Simoes et al., 2006;

Factors that influence disinfectant residual stability

There are many factors including water qualities and operating parameters that may directly or indirectly influence disinfectant residual stability. Water qualities refer to temperature, pH, nutrients, natural organic matter (NOM), dissolved oxygen (DO) and the presence of other potentially interacting species, such as bromide, iodide and corrosion products. There are five main operating parameters that have been considered among the literature: water age, hydraulic condition, pipe materials,

Conclusion

The influencing parameters of disinfectant stability have been qualitatively investigated in this review. These factors are not completely independent and may lead to positive feedback loops, such that microbial growth leads to a rapid decay of disinfectant residual further promoting microbial growth.

The types and dosages of disinfectants would be the most important factors affecting disinfectant stability. Disinfectant stability can be reduced by higher temperature and more microbial

Acknowledgements

This work was funded by Australian Research Council [ARC LP1601009099]. The authors are grateful to the support from Sydney Water Corporation, Seqwater, Queensland Urban Utilities (QUU), Unity Water and Logan City Council. RL is supported by Australian Government Research Training Program Scholarship (RTP) and UNSW Faculty of Engineering Top-up Scholarship. RL is thankful to Mr Joel Tan (UNSW) for proofreading this article.

References (183)

  • S. Chowdhury et al.

    Models for predicting disinfection byproduct (DBP) formation in drinking waters: a chronological review

    Sci. Total Environ.

    (2009)
  • C.W. Chu et al.

    Effect of oxalic acid on the regrowth of heterotrophic bacteria in the distributed drinking water

    Chemosphere

    (2004)
  • C.W. Chu et al.

    Effects of inorganic nutrients on the regrowth of heterotrophic bacteria in drinking water distribution systems

    J. Environ. Manag.

    (2005)
  • F. Codony et al.

    Role of discontinuous chlorination on microbial production by drinking water biofilms

    Water Res.

    (2005)
  • M. Deborde et al.

    Reactions of chlorine with inorganic and organic compounds during water treatment—kinetics and mechanisms: a critical review

    Water Res.

    (2008)
  • I. Douterelo et al.

    The bacteriological composition of biomass recovered by flushing an operational drinking water distribution system

    Water Res.

    (2014)
  • I. Douterelo et al.

    Influence of hydraulic regimes on bacterial community structure and composition in an experimental drinking water distribution system

    Water Res.

    (2013)
  • K. Fish et al.

    Biofilm structures (EPS and bacterial communities) in drinking water distribution systems are conditioned by hydraulics and influence discolouration

    Sci. Total Environ.

    (2017)
  • I. Fisher et al.

    Effects of stratification on chloramine decay in distribution system service reservoirs

    Water Res.

    (2009)
  • J. Fu et al.

    The influence of Cu(II) on the decay of monochloramine

    Chemosphere

    (2009)
  • M. Gouider et al.

    Impact of orthophosphate addition on biofilm development in drinking water distribution systems

    J. Hazard Mater.

    (2009)
  • N.B. Hallam et al.

    The decay of chlorine associated with the pipe wall in water distribution systems

    Water Res.

    (2002)
  • N.B. Hallam et al.

    The potential for biofilm growth in water distribution systems

    Water Res.

    (2001)
  • B.S. Herath et al.

    Can microbes significantly accelerate chloramine decay without severe nitrification?

    Int. Biodeterior. Biodegrad.

    (2015)
  • B.S. Herath et al.

    Effects of feed water NOM variation on chloramine demand from chloramine-decaying soluble microbial products during dechlorination

    Chemosphere

    (2018)
  • J. Hu et al.

    Enhanced formation of bromate and brominated disinfection byproducts during chlorination of bromide-containing waters under catalysis of copper corrosion products

    Water Res.

    (2016)
  • L. Kiene et al.

    Relative importance of the phenomena responsible for chlorine decay in drinking water distribution systems

    Water Sci. Technol.

    (1998)
  • S. Kinani et al.

    Analysis of inorganic chloramines in water

    Trac. Trends Anal. Chem.

    (2012)
  • B. Koudjonou et al.

    Formation of halogenated acetaldehydes, and occurrence in Canadian drinking water

    Chemosphere

    (2008)
  • E. Kumpel et al.

    Comparing microbial water quality in an intermittent and continuous piped water supply

    Water Res.

    (2013)
  • K. Lautenschlager et al.

    Overnight stagnation of drinking water in household taps induces microbial growth and changes in community composition

    Water Res.

    (2010)
  • J.Y. Lee et al.

    Effects of dissolved oxygen and iron aging on the reduction of trichloronitromethane, trichloracetonitrile, and trichloropropanone

    Chemosphere

    (2007)
  • J.Y. Lee et al.

    Degradation of trichloronitromethane by iron water main corrosion products

    Water Res.

    (2008)
  • M.J. Lehtola et al.

    The effects of changing water flow velocity on the formation of biofilms and water quality in pilot distribution system consisting of copper or polyethylene pipes

    Water Res.

    (2006)
  • M.J. Lehtola et al.

    Pipeline materials modify the effectiveness of disinfectants in drinking water distribution systems

    Water Res.

    (2005)
  • M.J. Lehtola et al.

    Microbiology, chemistry and biofilm development in a pilot drinking water distribution system with copper and plastic pipes

    Water Res.

    (2004)
  • M.F. Lemus Pérez et al.

    Exopolymeric substances from drinking water biofilms: dynamics of production and relation with disinfection by products

    Water Res.

    (2017)
  • C. Liu et al.

    Chlorination of bromide-containing waters: enhanced bromate formation in the presence of synthetic metal oxides and deposits formed in drinking water distribution systems

    Water Res.

    (2013)
  • G. Liu et al.

    Potential impacts of changing supply-water quality on drinking water distribution: a review

    Water Res.

    (2017)
  • J.-l. Liu et al.

    Characterization of soluble microbial products as precursors of disinfection byproducts in drinking water supply

    Sci. Total Environ.

    (2014)
  • S.C. Ma et al.

    Toward better understanding of chloral hydrate stability in water: kinetics, pathways, and influencing factors

    Chemosphere

    (2016)
  • J.P. Maestre et al.

    Monochloramine cometabolism by Nitrosomonas europaea under drinking water conditions

    Water Res.

    (2013)
  • C.M. Manuel et al.

    Dynamics of drinking water biofilm in flow/non-flow conditions

    Water Res.

    (2007)
  • R.A. Adhikari et al.

    Effect of biofilms grown at various chloramine residuals on chloramine decay

    Water Sci. Technol. Water Supply

    (2012)
  • M.A. Al-Zahrani

    Optimizing dosage and location of chlorine injection in water supply networks

    Arabian J. Sci. Eng.

    (2016)
  • W.A. Arnold et al.

    TBAA reduction in reactors simulating distribution system pipes

    J. AWWA (Am. Water Works Assoc.)

    (2010)
  • Australian Government
  • AWWA

    Effects of Water Age on Distribution System Water Quality

    (2002)
  • G.M. Ayoub et al.

    Impact of intermittent water supply on water quality in Lebanon

    Int. J. Environ. Pollut.

    (2006)
  • K. Bal Krishna et al.

    Effectiveness of re-chloramination to control nitrification in chloraminated bulk waters

    Desalination Water Treat.

    (2016)
  • Cited by (102)

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text