Brenda Cain and Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
Ranking 174 pasta sauces found in local grocery stores
CLEVELAND, Ohio – Everyone has a favorite way to dress their pasta and with jar sauce it feels like there's little middle ground: you either love it or hate it.
We're here to help you find a jar of sauce you will enjoy, whether you just need to get a weeknight dinner on the table or -- believe it or not -- are entertaining guests but don't have time to make marinara from scratch.
Behold, rankings of 174 pasta sauces we found and purchased at Greater Cleveland grocery stores for a gargantuan taste test.
They range in price from 85 cents(!) to $12.99.
Some of these sauces surprised us, and not always in a good way.
We went shopping at every major store and big box chain -- from Marc's to Trader Joe's and everywhere in between -- and chose up to two flavors from each brand on the shelves. If a brand offered a marinara, that was our first selection. We used the same brand of penne noodles for every sauce.
We ranked the 174 sauces from worst to best, with Classico Italian Sausage taking the ultimate No. 1 spot.
Another tidbit you may not believe: A sauce from Walmart's Sam's Choice brand made the Top 10.
See if you agree with the rankings. And we’d love to hear your go-to grocery store pasta sauce in the comments. Check out our rankings for 65 store-bought marinara sauces ranked from worst to best as well as rankings for 24 Alfredo sauces from grocery stores.
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 174 and No. 173
No. 174 Ohio City Pasta, Saffron Tomato
Label says: "This wonderfully crafted sauce is made with the finest ingredients and attention to detail. Made in small batches."
We say: This sauce was watery, so it did not adhere to the noodles. But worse than that, it had a bad metallic aftertaste, which lingered.
Sodium: 180 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $6.99
No. 173 Full Fork, Spicy Meaty
Label says: "Premium pasta sauce with meat. No artificial colors or flavorings. Gluten-free."
We say: Pasty is the best way to describe this sauce. You can see the meat, but it is completely tasteless.
Sodium: 290 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $7.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 172 and No. 171
No. 172 Riggo, Marinara Italiano
Label says: "Sauce made simple."
We say: Even though this sauce comes in a pouch, the taste is pure metal! It is extremely thick, so it was hard to swallow, as well.
Sodium: 450 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Fresh Thyme
Price: $3.99
No. 171 OrganicVille, Marinara
Label says: "OrganicVille's Marinara pasta sauce combines the highest quality organic vine-ripened tomatoes, fresh basil, oregano, onions and garlic. Made with 100% extra virgin olive oil and agave nectar. Sauce is certified organic, gluten-free and vegan."
We say: This dark sauce is very bitter and had a metallic taste, which lingers.
Sodium: 440 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $4.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 170 and No. 169
No. 170 Eden, Roma Tomatoes
Label says: "Made with organic extra virgin olive oil."
We say: We are not sure how sauce delivered in a glass jar can taste like metal, but this one sure packs a pure "tin can" flavor.
Sodium: 300 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $6.99
No. 169 Delallo, Traditional
Label says: "Premium sauce. All natural."
We say: This has a very strong acidic texture. The tomato taste is so strong, it covers everything else up.
Sodium: 340 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $3.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 168 and No. 167
No. 168 Prego, Traditional
Label says: No description, but the label does have a 3-step recipe for chicken parmesan. Yes, three steps.
We say: The taste is one of a sweet tomato paste, with a dash of oregano.
Sodium: 480 mg per serving
Sugar: 8 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $2.29
No. 167 Eden, Heirloom Variety
Label says: "Made with organic extra virgin olive oil."
We say: A dark red bitter sauce, with a metallic aftertaste.
Sodium: 420 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $6.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 166 and No. 165
No. 166 OrganicVille, Tomato Basil
Label says: "OrganicVille's Tomato Basil pasta sauce combines the highest quality organic vine-ripened tomatoes, fresh basil, onions, garlic and oregano. Made with 100% extra virgin olive oil and agave nectar. Sauce is certified organic, gluten free and vegan."
We say: This is not the worst organic sauce we tried, but it is very dark red, sweet and loaded with basil. It also has a metallic aftertaste.
Sodium: 420 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $4.99
No. 165 The Silver Palate, Roasted Garlic
Label says: "We blended imported San Marzano sweet tomatoes with famous California Rounds and extra virgin olive oil -- never tomato paste or added sugar."
We say: This sauce was very, very sweet, yet finished with a vinegar-y aftertaste. While you can see slivers of the garlic, the taste does not come through the tomatoes.
Sodium: 390 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $7.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 164 and No. 163
No. 164 The Silver Palate, Marinara
Label says: "We blended imported San Marzano sweet tomatoes with famous California Rounds and extra virgin olive oil -- never tomato paste or added sugar."
We say: This one will make you pucker your lips with its bitter and salty herbs.
Sodium: 360 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $7.99
No. 163 Brad's Organic, Tomato Basil
Label says: "Made with the finest organic ingredients. It's a rich hearty recipe that's so delicious it tastes like you are in mom's kitchen."
We say: Not our mom's kitchen. Shockingly sweet, with an overwhelming garlic and onion aftertaste.
Sodium: 95 mg per serving
Sugar: 10 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's
Price: $2.49
Brenda Cain, cleveland.com
We went shopping all over town looking for different brands and flavors of pasta sauce. Yes, we got some odd looks when we checked out.
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 162 and No. 161
No. 162 Yo Mama's, Basil
Label says: "Divinely crafted from garden-fresh tomatoes, garlic, onion, olive oil and basil. No added sugar, GMOs, preservatives or gluten."
We say: Thin and watery, this sauce has no taste!
Sodium: 125 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $7.99
No. 161 Engine 2, Organic Tomato Basil
Label says: "No added oils. No added sugar. 1/2 cup of vegetables."
We say: It's thin and watery, so it didn't stick to the noodles and didn't contain much flavor.
Sodium: 150 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $4.99
No. 160 and No. 159
No. 160 Vesper Bros. Foods, Marinara
Label says: "100% all-natural sauce."
We say: Appears and tastes like a plain tomato sauce from a can -- sans any seasonings.
Sodium: 290 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $6.99
No. 159 Cibo's, Meatless Pasta Sauce
Label says: "Since 1971 people from all over have traveled to Cibo's Restaurant in Waynesburg, Ohio to enjoy our homemade pastas and Italian sauces."
We say: This one smells like a homemade sauce, and is thick so it adheres well to the noodles. The taste, however, is disappointing. It tastes like a sweet tomato paste.
Sodium: 730 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's
Price: $4.29
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 158 and No. 157
No. 158 Michael's of Brooklyn, Filetto di Pomodoro
Label says: "Imported Italian tomatoes, onions, prosciutto, fresh basil, olive oil, spices, parsley and nothing else."
We say: This sauce was a real disappointment. It was so thin and watery, you almost need a straw. It delivers an almost overwhelming onion flavor.
Sodium: 260 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $9.49
No. 157 Terlato Kitchen, Pomodoro
Label says: "San Marzano tomatoes with extra virgin olive oil, sea salt, garlic and spices."
We say: Three words: Runny and flavorless!
Sodium: 280 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $8.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 156 and No. 155
No. 156 Corbo's, Pasta Sauce
Label says: "Cleveland's own Little Italy made pasta sauce. Meat free. 100% all natural. Low sodium."
We say: A traditional shop in Cleveland's Little Italy for pastry, maybe Corbo's should stick to the cannoli. While there was large chunks of vegetables, the sauce itself was thin and runny -- with no herbs or salt for flavoring. This one was bland and disappointing.
Sodium: 160 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's
Price: $4.99
No. 155 Little Italy, Marinara
Label says: "Freshly made. All natural."
We say: A thick sauce, which adhered well to the noodles, with chunks of garlic and spices, but little taste.
Sodium: 135 mg per serving
Sugar: 2 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $6.79
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 154 and No. 153
No. 154 Little Italy, Spicy Pasta Sauce
Label says: "Freshly made. All natural."
We say: Another thick sauce, which adhered well to the noodles, but sadly, we couldn't detect any spices. And this is supposed to be spicy!
Sodium: 135 mg per serving
Sugar: 2 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $6.79
No. 153 Barilla, Meat
Label says: "Italy's number one brand of pasta sauce. Real taste comes from real vegetables."
We say: This sauce had a definite vinegar-y aftertaste, in spite of being sweet when it first hits your tongue. It was a bit on the metallic side, as well.
Sodium: 520 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's
Price: $2.00
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 152 and No. 151
No. 152 DeMassimo's, Authentic Pasta Sauce
Label says: "From Abruzzo, Italy, to your home, this classic tomato sauce has an 'Old World' taste that is unrivaled and has been in the DeMassimo family for generations."
We say: Thick and smooth, this sauce delivered a bitter aftertaste.
Sodium: 310 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $4.79
No. 151 Seggiano, Marinara Garlic
Label says: "A vegan version of the classic marinara recipe, with generous amounts of fresh garlic. Made in Sicily."
We say: A super thick sauce with large chunks of vegetables, but it tasted more like a pure tomato pureé.
Sodium: 360 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $8.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 150 and No. 149
No. 150 Full Fork, Traditional Marinara
Label says: "Premium pasta sauce with meat. No artificial colors or flavorings. Gluten free."
We say: Even though this sauce comes in a glass jar, it has a strong metallic flavor and the herbs are bitter.
Sodium: 240 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $7.99
No. 149 Nature's Basket, Vodka Pasta Sauce
Label says: "Gluten-free.No artificial colors, flavors or preservatives. Non-GMO"
We say: Not much of an aroma or taste, instead it offers a sweet tin can flavor.
Sodium: 340 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $1.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 148 and No. 147
No. 148 Racconto, Classic Marinara
Label says: "Made from hand-selected vine-ripened tomatoes. Each variety is made with the freshest ingredients for your family's enjoyment."
We say: The oregano and tomato tastes overwhelm all else, except for the salt.
Sodium: 560 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Fresh Thyme
Price: $4.99
No. 147 Market District, Marinara
Label says: "Expertly crafted from ripe Italian tomatoes, onions, garlic and spices."
We say: The flavor of this sauce was so mild it was completely overwhelmed by the taste of the pasta.
Sodium: 420 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $6.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 146 and No. 145
No. 146 Nellino's Sauce Co., Marinara
Label says: "U.S. grown tomatoes. U.S. crafted. Homegrown story. Homemade taste."
We say: Thin and runny with a crushed tomato consistency, this sauce was sweet and bland.
Sodium: 250 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $8.99
No. 145 Stino da Napoli, Fumo del Vesuvio
Label says: "Smoked bacon gives this creamy tomato sauce its flavorful taste and distinctive name, evoking the alove volcano, Vesuvius."
We say: This sauce brought on the most spirited discussion among the team. While one team member referred to it as "breakfast pasta sauce" because it reminded her of "runny scrambled eggs," another member suffered a violent reaction to it. To each his own.
Sodium: 215 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $5.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 144 and No. 143
No. 144 Fit & Active, Traditional Pasta Sauce
Label says: "No preservatives. No Cholesterol or Saturated Fat. 0g Trans Fat."
We say: This acidic sauce tastes like you are eating crushed tomatoes straight from the can.
Sodium: 25 mg per serving
Sugar: 8 g per serving
Where we bought it: Aldi's
Price: $1.39
No. 143 Victoria Trading Company, Marinara
Label says: "Imported Italian Plum Tomatoes, fresh onions, imported olive oil and spices."
We say: This is the first sauce we tried that had that "simmered for an afternoon" flavor, though it remained runny and was a bit over-salted.
Sodium: 420 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Walmart
Price: $3.48
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 142 and No. 141
No. 142 Gia Russo, Spaghetti Dinner Sauce
Label says: "This rich old-fashioned tomato sauce is perfect for simmering all day with meatballs or for a quick weeknight dinner."
We say: Slightly better than other traditional sauces on the market, but still a little on the sweet side and with very little detectable mushroom flavor.
Sodium: 420 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $7.99
No. 141 Muir Glen, Classic Marinara
Label says: "Organic. Non-GMO certified. No sugar added."
We say: Finally! A sauce that delivered pure tomato taste with big chunks of tomato throughout.
Sodium: 390 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $3.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 140 and No. 139
No. 140 Monte Bene, Spicy Marinara
Label says: "Gluten free, no preservatives, no sugar added."
We say: A pure tomato sauce, with a slight bite."
Sodium: 240 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $4.99
No. 139 Del Grosso, Sunday Marinara
Label says: "Ultra-premium pasta sauce. America's oldest family sauce-maker."
We say: While it has a fresh tomato flavor, it was a little on the flat and salty side.
Sodium: 420 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $6.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 138 and No. 137
No. 138 Tito Francona & Son Pasta Sauce, Tomato Basil
Label says: "Enjoy every exciting inning while enjoying the same pasta sauce Tito and Terry enjoyed growing up. Made with the finest Italian ingredients."
We say: There is little to cheer about with this sauce. It is sweet and vinegary and a tad bit salty.
Sodium: 380 mg per serving
Sugar: 8 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's
Price: $3.49
While Terry Francona sees his side hustle of selling pasta sauce as a legacy to his late father -- former Indian's first baseman TIto Francona -- Tito & Son's pasta sauce has, also, become a real boon to the Cleveland Indian's Charities.
No. 137 Fit & Active, Tomato Onion and Garlic
Label says: "No preservatives. No Cholesterol or Saturated Fat. 0g Trans Fat."
We say: This one is sweet, with a strong onion aroma and a strong aftertaste.
Sodium: 25 mg per serving
Sugar: 8 g per serving
Where we bought it: Aldi's
Price: $1.39
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 136 and No. 135
No. 136 Victoria, Marinara
Label says: "100% Italian tomatoes. Imported Olive Oil. Fresh Garlic."
We say: It has that "simmered all afternoon" taste, but is so extremely salty, it was difficult to eat.
Sodium: 420 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $7.49
No. 135 Johnny's, Marinara
Label says: No description.
We say: This sauce was so disappointing, with its oily, mild taste and a strong garlic aftertaste.
Sodium: 240 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's
Price: $5.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 134 and No. 133
No. 134 Food Club, Chunky Traditional
Label says: "No artificial colors, flavors or preservatives."
We say: Lacked the "chunky" pieces promised on the label.
Sodium: 480 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Dave's Supermarket
Price: $1.99
No. 133 Gia Russo, Traditional
Label says: "This rich old-fashioned tomato sauce is perfect for simmering all day with meatballs or for a quick weeknight dinner."
We say: Truth in advertising in that it smells like a homemade Sunday sauce, with a sweet oregano flavor.
Sodium: 420 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's
Price: $1.39
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 132 and No. 131
No. 132 Cibo's, Pasta Sauce with Meat
Label says: "Since 1971 people from all over have traveled to Cibo's Restaurant in Waynesburg, Ohio, to enjoy our homemade pastas and sauces."
We say: The over-the-top tomato taste drowns out any meat -- or pasta -- flavor.
Sodium: 690 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's
Price: $4.29
No. 131 Reggano, Traditional
Label says: "A full serving of vegetables. Low in fat. A good source of fiber."
We say: A typical sweet jar sauce, with a mild oregano flavor.
Sodium: 500 mg per serving
Sugar: 8 g per serving
Where we bought it: Aldi's
Price: $0.85
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 130 and No. 129
No. 130 Hunt's, Traditional
Label says: No description.
We say: Hard to describe this sauce other than "bland." It tastes like it was made for kids.
Sodium: 560 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Save-A-Lot
Price: $0.99
No. 129 Ferratto's, Four Cheese
Label says: No description.
We say: While it has a slow-simmered look, it is a bit on the sweet side. You can taste the cheese, but it is light on flavor.
Sodium: 450 mg per serving
Sugar: 8 g per serving
Where we bought it: Save-A-Lot
Price: $1.69
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 128 and No. 127
No. 128 Great Value, Parmesan Romano
Label says: "Only wholesome ingredients with no artificial flavors or preservatives to deliver great foods you can trust. Honest taste. Great Value."
We say: Where's the cheese? Not in this flat-tasting sauce.
Sodium: 430 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Walmart
Price: $1.98
No. 127 Emeril's, Kicked Up Tomato
Label says: "This sauce has won awards. If you like things a little spicy you are gonna love it. Lots of tomatoes, onions, with Italian seasonings, good oil and some garlic, with a touch of hot sauce."
We say: Kicked up? Not so much. With its bright red color and large chunks of tomato it does look freshly made. But it is not big on flavor.
Sodium: 440 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's
Price: $2.55
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 126 and No. 125
No. 126 Mia's Kitchen, Kale
Label says: "No cholesterol, vegan, gluten-free, dairy free."
We say: True to its name, this sauce offers strong kale flavor, but is a bit overwhelmed by the onion and garlic. It so thin and watery it is more like soup.
Sodium: 400 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $8.99
No. 125 Hunt's, Meat-flavored Sauce
Label says: No description.
We say: There is no visible meat in the sauce, nor is there any meat flavor.
Sodium: 610 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Save-A-Lot
Price: $0.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 124 and No. 123
No. 124: 365 Everyday Value, Organic Portobello Mushroom
Label says: "Fat-free, pure goodness, highest quality."
We say: Small, sporadic pieces of mushroom were hard to detect in this thin, runny sauce. It did offer a strong garlic aroma.
Sodium: 410 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $2.79
No. 123 Simply Nature, Organic Tomato & Basil
Label says: "No artificial flavors, colors or preservatives. Gluten-free."
We say: A darker and thicker sauce than most, it does have a rich basil and tomato flavor.
Sodium: 470 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Aldi's
Price: $2.19
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 122 and No. 121
No. 122 Pasta Too, Tomato
Label says: "Made in small batches by small hands for precious homemade flavor."
We say: The "small hands" reference could explain why it tastes like a kid sauce. And those kids were pretty heavy-handed with the salt shaker.
Sodium: 340 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $6.99
No. 121 Organico Bello, Tomato Basil
Label says: "Made with 100% organic Italian tomatoes."
We say: The basil is lost in the strong tomato sauce.
Sodium: 230 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $7.49
Brenda Cain and Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
Can you believe how many different sauces are on store shelves? In some stores, they took up half an aisle.
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 120 and No. 119
No. 120 Muir Glen, Organic Cabernet
Label says: "Our founder's commitment to organic agriculture led to our name, a nod to John Muir, father of the National Parks.
We say: A watery sauce that smells and tastes like wine and leaves you with a definite aftertaste.
Sodium: 280 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $3.99
No. 119 Paesana, Marinara
Label says: "Made with 100% imported Italian tomatoes. Gluten-free."
We say: The processed tomatoes are slightly sweet but deliver a fresh taste.
Sodium: 400 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $7.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 118 and No. 117
No. 118 Giant Eagle, Garden Style
Label says: "Gluten-free."
We say: Plenty of chunks of vegetables populate this thin sauce. Sadly, all you can taste is the peppers and onions.
Sodium: 440 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $1.39
No. 117 The Meatball Shop, Classic Tomato Sauce
Label says: "Vegetarian."
We say: You won't find any meatballs in this sauce, but you will find lots of chunks of tomato and oil.
Sodium: 480 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $8.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 116 and No. 115
No. 116 Newman's Own, Marinara
Label says: "Made with extra-virgin olive oil. No sugar added."
We say: Too sweet. Not too much flavor.
Sodium: 490 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $2.99
No. 115 Food Club, Chunky Garden Combination
Label says: "No artificial colors, flavor or preservatives."
We say: Lacks any "chunky" it promises on the label. Has a very generic jar sauce taste.
Sodium: 480 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Dave's Supermarket
Price: $1.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 114 and No. 113
No. 114 Giant Eagle, Traditional Pasta Sauce
Label says: "Gluten-free."
We say: This is a very sweet sauce.
Sodium: 400 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $1.39
No. 113 Ohio City Pasta, Fine Herb Marinara
Label says: "This wonderfully crafted sauce is made with the finest ingredients and attention to detail, made in small batches."
We say: This was so disappointing for a local pasta sauce. It was thin, watery and had very little flavor.
Sodium: 310 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $6.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 112 and No. 111
No. 112 Mezzetta, Marinara
Label says: "Made with sweet and rich plum tomatoes."
We say: A thick sauce that's not as sweet as you might expect given the label's description.
Sodium: 520 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $5.99
No. 111: 365 Everyday Value, Organic Marinara
Label says: "Fat-free, pure goodness, highest quality."
We say: This sauce has a thick consistency, with lots -- and lots -- of oregano.
Sodium: 410 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $2.79
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 110 and No. 109
No. 110 Organico Bello, Marinara
Label says: "Made with 100% organic Italian tomatoes."
We say: Not bad for an organic sauce, but delivers a slight metallic aftertaste.
Sodium: 230 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $7.49
No. 109 Market Pantry, Tomato, Basil & Garlic
Label says: "1-1/2 servings of vegetables per half cup."
We say: There is a good combination of vegetables in this flavorful sauce.
Sodium: 420 mg per serving
Sugar: 9 g per serving
Where we bought it: Target
Price: $0.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 108 and No. 107
No. 108 Great Value, Organic Marinara
Label says: "Only wholesome ingredients with no artificial flavors or preservatives to deliver great foods you can trust. Honest taste. Great Value."
We say: While it has plenty of big chunks of tomato and onion in this sauce, all you can taste is the onion.
Sodium: 430 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Walmart
Price: $1.98
No. 107 Zack Bruell, Marinara
Label says: "For more than 30 years, Zack Bruell has been a driver of culinary innovation in the city of Cleveland and beyond. As a restaurateur and chef behind Cleveland's Parallax, Table 45, L'Albatros, Chinato, Dynomite, Cowell and Hubbard and Alley Cat, Bruell is known for bold and artistic flavor combinations -- and this sauce is no exception."
We say: A solid sauce with a pleasing flavor.
Sodium: 560 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Dave's Supermarket
Price: $6.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 106 and No. 105
No. 106 Simply Balanced, Organic Marinara
Label says: "No artificial colors or flavors."
We say: This sauce offers a strong tomato flavor, with a slight aftertaste. Nothing else.
Sodium: 480 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Target
Price: $2.09
No. 105 Brad's Organic, Classic Marinara
Label says: "Made with only the finest organic ingredients. It's a rich, hearty recipe that's so delicious it tastes like you are in mom's kitchen."
We say: This dark red, thick sauce offers a shockingly sweet flavor.
Sodium: 95 mg per serving
Sugar: 10 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's Supermarket
Price: $2.49
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 104 and No. 103
No. 104 Earth Fare, Organic Portobello Mushroom
Label says: "Made with organic extra virgin olive oil."
We say: Plenty of chunks of onion visible, but no mushrooms in sight. Not much flavor, either.
Sodium: 340 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $2.99
No. 103 Yo Mama's, Marinara
Label says: "Lovingly made in small batches for delectable flavors. Our mama-approved recipe contains no added sugars, GMOs, preservatives or gluten."
We say: Nothing more than a runny sauce with a strong taste of onions.
Sodium: 210 mg per serving
Sugar: 2 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $7.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 102 and No. 101
No. 102 The Blonde Italian, Rosa Roma
Label says: "The Roma tomatoes, fresh cream garlic and herbs in this sauce creates a nice finish for your favorite pasta."
We say: Almost pink in appearance, it is not very appealing to look at. It doesn't offer much appeal in the flavor department either with its overpowering garlic flavor that is almost bitter.
Sodium: 690 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's Supermarket
Price: $4.99
No. 101 Marinelli's, Slow Roasted Whole Garlic
Label says: "True Italian pasta sauce made old school with slow-roasted whole garlic."
We say: While it is a little on the salty side, this one did have a smoky garlic flavor.
Sodium: 380 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $9.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 100 and No. 99
No. 100 Dave's Gourmet, Organic Red Heirloom
Label says: "Organic vine-ripened tomatoes, premium California garlic, extra-virgin olive oil and fresh herbs combine to create a delicious sauce that is light, fresh and bursting with flavor."
We say: There are plenty of chunks of tomato, but very little flavor.
Sodium: 280 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $6.99
No. 99 Simply Nature, Organic Marinara
Label says: "No artificial flavors, colors or preservatives. Gluten-free."
We say: This was so sugary, it made us wince!"
Sodium: 490 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Aldi's
Price: $2.19
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 98 and No. 97
No. 98 Mid's, Mideo's Marinara
Label says: "All natural. Kettle simmered for hours."
We say: So dark red and thick, the appearance reminded us of ketchup. Just as sugary too.
Sodium: 400 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $4.49
No. 97 Ferratto's, Tomato Basil
Label says: No description.
We say: This one smells like a jar of fresh tomatoes, and tastes like one too!
Sodium: 410 mg per serving
Sugar: 9 g per serving
Where we bought it: Save-A-Lot
Price: $1.69
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 96 and No. 95
No. 96 Victoria Trading Company, Arrabbiata
Label says: "Imported Italian Plum tomatoes, fresh onions, crushed red pepper, imported olive oil and spices."
We say: While you expect heat at first bite with any arrabbiata, the spiciness was slow to get started in this one.
Sodium: 420 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Walmart
Price: $3.48
No. 95 Cucina Antica, Garlic Marinara
Label says: "No sugar added. Non-GMO project verified. No preservatives."
We say: Looks and tastes like crushed tomatoes with some oregano, not much else.
Sodium: 210 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $7.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 94 and No. 93
No. 94 Trader Giotto's, Three Cheese
Label says: "Slowly simmered Italian Plum tomatoes and aged cheese."
We say: Salty, salty, salty. It tastes like Chef Boyardee made this one.
Sodium: 500 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Trader Joe's
Price: $2.49
No. 93 Dave's Gourmet, Butternut Squash
Label says: "Thoughtfully crafted with Willamette Valley butternut squash, fresh garlic, onions, roasted red peppers, our gold medal winner for "Best Pasta Sauce" brings gourmet taste to your table."
We say: With its sweet and fruity aroma, this thick chunky sauce is full of vegetables. The sweetness and the spiciness meld well together.
Sodium: 385 mg per serving
Sugar: 9 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $6.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 92 and No. 91
No. 92 Tito Francona & Son, Marinara
Label says: "Enjoy every exciting inning while enjoying the same pasta sauce Tito and Terry enjoyed growing up. Made with the finest Italian ingredients."
We say: We'll call this one a "double." It has the consistency of a tomato bisque, with a slight vinegar after-taste. Still a solid sauce.
Sodium: 390 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 gm per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's
Price: $3.49
No. 91 Il Mulino, Marinara
Label says: "Decadent signature sauce."
We say: Wear a bib with this one. The layer of oil on top was difficult to mix in, but it has large chunks of tomato and garlic, which, after the oil is well-blended, makes it taste almost homemade.
Sodium: 480 mg per serving
Sugar: 2 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $12.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 90 and No. 89
No. 90 Nature's Basket, Organic Marinara
Label says: "Gluten-free. No artificial colors, flavors or preservatives. Non-GMO."
We say: This sauce has a very bitter processed flavor, with a bit of a metallic aftertaste.
Sodium: 330 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $1.99
No. 89 Lucini, Tuscan Marinara
Label says: "Crafted in small batches with Lucini Virgin Olive Oil."
We say: This sauce has the texture and the taste of stewed tomatoes. It's on the sweet side.
Sodium: 310 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $7.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 88 and No. 87
No. 88 Barilla, Traditional
Label says: "Italy's #1 brand of pasta sauce. Real taste comes from real vegetables."
We say: A strong onion aroma almost overcomes any tomato taste. There are plenty of small pieces of garlic visible in the sauce.
Sodium: 420 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's Supermarket
Price: $2
No. 87 Heinen's, Organic Italian Herb
Label says: "USDA certified organic, non-GMO verified."
We say: "Slightly" is the word for this sauce. Slightly chunky (with mostly onion). A thick sauce that is slightly salty.
Sodium: 500 mg per serving
Sugar: 9 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $3.29
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 86 and No. 85
No. 86 Terlato Kitchen, Vodka Sauce
Label says: "San Marzano tomatoes, heavy cream, vodka, Italian extra-virgin olive oil, butter, sea salt, garlic and spices."
We say: If you love cheese, this creamy sauce has a strong Romano aroma and flavor.
Sodium: 310 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $8.99
No. 85 Jar Goods, Classic Red
Label says: "Non-GMO project verified, minimally processed, vegan, kosher."
We say: Smells slow-simmered. A nice and thick sauce with a bright tomato flavor.
Sodium: 390 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $7.19
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 84 and No. 83
No. 84 Rizzo's Malabar Inn, Marinara
Label says: "Homemade."
We say: Strong garlic notes in this tomato-y sauce. Goldilocks would say it is not too sweet and not too salty.
Sodium: 380 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $2.99
No. 83 Bertolli, Traditional Marinara
Label says: "Made with 100% olive oil, Italian herbs and fresh garlic."
We say: Bright red sauce with plenty of chunks of tomato and onion -- and lots of oregano. This is a very sweet-tasting, thick sauce.
Sodium: 490 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $3.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 82 and No. 81
No. 82 Hand Picked, Arrabbiata
Label says: "With sweet Italian tomatoes. A zesty Sunday gravy made with chili flakes, garlic and spices."
We say: This Arrabbiata smells and tastes a bit like a canned pizza sauce. The kick comes later."
Sodium: 380 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $6.99
No. 81 Our Lady of Mt. Carmel Basilica, Spaghetti Dinner Sauce
Label says: "Our spaghetti dinner sauce has been a favorite of our parishioners, and the Youngstown area, for many years. We are happy to bring it to your home."
We say: This oregano-laden thick sauce has a nice consistency. There is plenty of the Italian herb to love in this one.
Sodium: 570 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's Supermarket
Price: $3.79
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 80 and No. 79
No. 80 Little Italy of the Bronx, Alla Vodka
Label says: "Crafted from Italian tomatoes, Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese and crushed red pepper. No preservatives. No sugar added."
We say: We had a bit of difficulty blending the thick layer of oil atop the sauce when we opened the jar. Once we worked it into the sauce, it was a bit runny and not big on flavor.
Sodium: 360 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $6.99
No. 79 Rao's Homemade, Four Cheese
Label says: "A smooth blend of vine-ripened tomatoes and four classic Italian cheeses, with onions and garlic."
We say: Good consistency. Good flavor. Unlike many cheese sauces, the cheeses were not too overwhelming.
Sodium: 400 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $7.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 78 and No. 77
No. 78 Yellow Barn, Arrabbiata
Label says: "Biodynamic. Made through agriculture with absolutely no tolerance for added hormone, synthetic pesticides or GMOs."
We say: This sauce is chock full of olives and is super hot!
Sodium: 260 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $7.99
No. 77 Vesper Bros. Foods, Tomato Basil
Label says: "Our #1 best-selling tomato sauce, full of rich sweet tomato flavor and a fragrant burst of basil, perfect for both slow simmers and a quick pasta."
We say: This sauce offers a good balance between the tomatoe and basil flavors, though slightly on the sweet side.
Sodium: 290 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $6.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 76 and No. 75
No. 76 Ragu, Meat
Label says: "Rich and smooth."
We say: A rich sauce, though the team was split on the amount of meat in the sauce and how much flavor it provided.
Sodium: 480 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $1.79
No. 75 Dei Fratelli, Traditional
Label says: "The best sauce starts with the best tomatoes. All natural. Made with Sea Salt."
We say: Thick and rich consistency, but aside from the oregano, it has little flavor.
Sodium: 430 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's Supermarket
Price: $2
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 74 and No. 73
No. 74 Mia's Kitchen, Bistro Marinara
Label says: "No cholesterol, vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free."
We say: An extremely runny sauce, without much flavor.
Sodium: 400 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $8.99
No. 73 De Massimo's, Arrabbiata
Label says: "From San Giovanni, to Galdo, Italy, to your home, this Arrabbiata sauce adds a subtle kick to heat up your taste buds. For generations we have enjoyed this unique sauce complete with petite diced tomatoes and quality herbs and spices."
We say: Plenty of large chunks of tomato, in a runny sauce, with a slight kick.
Sodium: 360 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $4.79
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 72 and No. 71
No. 72 Little Italy of the Bronx, Marinara
Label says: "Crafted from imported Italian tomatoes and slivers of fresh garlic. No preservatives. No sugar added."
We say: This is a very oily sauce without much taste.
Sodium: 480 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $6.99
No. 71 Earth Fare Organic, Marinara
Label says: "Made with organic extra-virgin olive oil. Over 1/2 cup of vegetables in every serving."
We say: A thick sauce with a sweet and vinegar-y flavor. The taste of the pasta almost overpowered the flavor of this sauce.
Sodium: 330 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $2.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 70 and No. 69
No. 70 Racconto, Cabernet
Label says: "Made from hand-selected, vine-ripened tomatoes. Each variety is made with the freshest ingredients for your family's enjoyment."
We say: Big oregano flavor. The wine was strong in this one, which made it a tad bitter.
Sodium: 560 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Fresh Thyme
Price: $4.99
No. 69 Cucina Antica, Arrabbiata
Label says: "No sugar added. Non-GMO project verified. No preservatives."
We say: If you like a kick from your pasta sauce, this is not the one for you. For an arrabbiata, this one has little-to-no burn.
Sodium: 210 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $7.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
The counter top for our taste tests was full of a variety of sauces.
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 68 and No. 67
No. 68 Mantia's, Traditional
Label says: "Lou Mantia's kitchen is fragrant with Italian spices and warmed by spirited conversation. Bring your friends and family together around a home-cooked meal that is delicious and simple to prepare."
We say: This sauce is fragrant with Italian herbs, but on the sweet side."
Sodium: 510 mg per serving
Sugar: 9 g per serving
Where we bought it: Save-A-Lot
Price: $1.39
No. 67 Engine 2, Organic Firehouse Kale
Label says: "No added oils. No added sugar. 1/2 cup of vegetables in each serving."
We say: A very thin sauce with small chunks of tomatoes and shreds of kale. But beware, this one is HOT!
Sodium: 140 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $4.99
Brenda Cain and Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 66 and No. 65
No. 66 Trader Giotto's, Tomato Basil Marinara
Label says: "Slow-simmered Italian Plum tomatoes and basil."
We say: Sweet oregano... oh, wait -- it's supposed to be basil!
Sodium: 580 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Trader Joe's
Price: $1.79
No. 65 Carfagna's, Vodka Sauce
Label says: "Local product. 100% natural. 0% Trans Fat. Gluten-free."
We say: A thick and creamy sauce, but with a Chef Boyardee bent.
Sodium: 340 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $7.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 64 and No. 63
No. 64 Paesana, Tomato Basil
Label says: "Made with 100% imported Italian tomatoes from our organic family recipe."
We say: Oily -- with an onion, basil and tomato salsa flavor!
Sodium: 400 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $7.99
No. 63 Stancato's, Premier Pasta Sauce
Label says: "Smooth, house-made with Roma tomatoes. Will turn any meal into an Italian feast."
We say: A very simple sauce. Nice flavor and consistency.
Sodium: 350 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $4.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 62 and No. 61
No. 62 Hand Picked, Marinara
Label says: "With sweet Italian tomatoes. A zesty Sunday gravy made with pure olive oil."
We say: It looks and smells slow-simmered, but this sauce is very oily.
Sodium: 380 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $6.99
No. 61 The Blonde Italian, Robusto Hearty Marinara
Label says: "This robust flavor comes from vine-ripened tomatoes, herbs and real food spices with a touch of sunflower oil."
We say: A very thick, sweet and very salty sauce.
Sodium: 690 mg per serving
Sugar: 8 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's Supermarket
Price: $4.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 60 and No. 59
No. 60 Michael's of Brooklyn, Marinara Sauce
Label says: "Imported Italian tomatoes, fresh garlic, fresh basil, Italian olive oil, oregano, fresh parsley and spices. Nothing else!"
We say: We were expecting more based on the label. Sparse slivers of garlic and shreds of parsley, but we needed more. Thin and watery.
Sodium: 320 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $9.49
No. 59 Emeril's, Tomato and Basil
Label says: "Loaded with tomatoes, good oil, onions and delicate spice blend."
We say: Heavy on the basil and the sweetness. Very small chunks of tomatoes. A basic sauce.
Sodium: 430 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's Supermarket
Price: $2.55
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 58 and No. 57
No. 58 Inspired Organics, Classic Marinara
Label says: "A rich flavorful sauce great for pasta, veggies and meats. Made with crushed tomatoes, roasted garlic and yellow onions."
We say: Not huge on the taste, but not overly sweet or salty either.
Sodium: 300 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Dave's Supermarket
Price: $4.99
No. 57 Rizzo's Malabar Inn, Three Cheese
Label says: "Homemade."
We say: Looks like tomato soup with a heavy parm flavor.
Sodium: 320 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $2.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 56 and No. 55
No. 56 Nellio's Sauce Co., Hot & Spicy
Label says: "U.S. grown tomatoes. U.S. crafted. Homegrown story. Homemade taste."
We say: This one is "heartburn hot!"
Sodium: 250 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $8.99
No. 55 Godmother's, Roasted Red Pepper
Label says: "Made with red peppers, vine-ripened tomatoes, celery, carrots, onions, garlic, olive oil, salt and spices. It is slowly simmered in an open kettle all day."
We say: True to its name, it is very pepper-y indeed, but it is also thin and runny.
Sodium: 570 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $7.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 54 and No. 53
No. 54 Francesco Rinaldi, Sausage
Label says: "Sicilian family recipe. Made with extra-virgin olive oil."
We say: A hearty garden-style sauce with plenty of chunks of veggies and shredded sausage.
Sodium: 550 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's Supermarket
Price: $
No. 53 Yellow Barn, Puttanesca
Label says: "Biodynamic. Made through agriculture with absolutely no tolerance for added hormones, synthetic pesticides or GMOs."
We say: A spicy tomato sauce with nice chunks of olives. It has an ever-so-slight metallic aftertaste.
Sodium: 240 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $7.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 52 and No. 51
No. 52 Riggo, Italian Sausage
Label says: "Sauce made simple!"
We say: Truth in advertising. It is a simple sauce with plenty of sausage. Good flavor.
Sodium: 610 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Fresh Thyme
Price: $3.99
No. 51 Marinelli's, Classic Marinara
Label says: "True Italian pasta sauce made old school."
We say: Smooth and processed. Smells fresh but has a disappointing taste, given the appearance and aroma.
Sodium: 380 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $9.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
Enough sauce? The jars felt never-ending.
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 50 and No. 49
No. 50 Inspired Organics, Tomato & Basil
Label says: "A savory tomato sauce great for pasta, veggies and meats. Made with Italian tomatoes, sweet basil and roasted garlic."
We say: This sauce is a lot like eating a can of crushed tomatoes, smothered in basil.
Sodium: 200 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Dave's Supermarket
Price: $4.99
No. 49 Priano, Marinara
Label says: "Inspired by Italy. No artificial flavors."
We say: Tomato paste-y taste with chunks of tomatoes and just a hint of garlic. It's a little on the sweet side as well.
Sodium: 480 mg per serving
Sugar: 9 g per serving
Where we bought it: Aldi's
Price: $1.89
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 48 and No. 47
No. 48 Market Pantry, Marinara
Label says: "1-1/2 servings of vegetables in 1/2 cup serving."
We say: Thin and runny, though not bad tasting, for a store brand. It did have flavor.
Sodium: 480 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Target
Price: $0.99
No. 47 Pasta Too, Meat Flavored
Label says: "Made in small batches by small hands for a precious homemade flavor."
We say: This tasted more cheese-based than a meat-flavored sauce. A good balance with the sweetness.
Sodium: 240 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $6.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 46 and No. 45
No. 46 Francesco Rinaldi, Original Recipe
Label says: "Original recipe. Made with imported Pecorino Romano cheese and extra-virgin olive oil."
We say: A good, basic sauce with a good consistency.
Sodium: 550 mg per serving
Sugar: 8 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's Supermarket
Price: $2
No. 45 La Vera, Traditional (with pork)
Label says: "Family operated. Locally produced."
We say: Small chunks of meat populate this sauce, giving it a good flavor in spite of being a bit on the oily side.
Sodium: 670 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Dave's Supermarket
Price: $4.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 44 and No. 43
No. 44 Delallo, Vodka Sauce
Label says: "Premium sauce. All natural. We use Pecorino Romano cheese, ripe tomatoes and savory garlic to create our rich velvety Vodka Sauce. Made with all natural ingredients this smooth tomato cream sauce is blended with a touch of vodka to release the full flavor of the tomato."
We say: A nice creamy appearance, with big chunks of tomatoes, but the cheese is overwhelming.
Sodium: 280 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $3.99
No. 43 Sugo di Pomodoro, Marinara
Label says: No description.
We say: A heavy sweetness is tempered only by a heavy onion taste and aroma.
Sodium: 370 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $7.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 42 and No. 41
No. 42 Del Grosso, Roasted Garlic Gala
Label says: "Ultra-premium pasta sauce from America's oldest family sauce maker."
We say: A thick sauce that is not as overpowering as you may think from the label.
Sodium: 420 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $6.99
No. 41 Sugo di Pomodoro, Creamy Vodka Sauce
Label says: No description.
We say: While the aroma is pleasant, this pasta sauce is darker than most vodka sauces. OK taste, but watery.
Sodium: 430 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $7.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 40 and No. 39
No. 40 Godmother's, Marinara
Label says: "Made with vine-ripened tomatoes, fresh onions and garlic, olive oil, salt and spices. It is slowly simmered in an open kettle all day."
We say: The oregano and garlic really shine in this one. A solid sauce with a rich flavor.
Sodium: 420 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $6.99
No. 39 Trattoria, Tomato Basil
Label says: "100% natural. No preservatives."
We say: A true homemade taste with bright fresh tomato flavor and slight hints of basil.
Sodium: 260 mg per serving
Sugar: 2 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $6.49
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 38 and No. 37
No. 38 Market District, Spicy Arrabbiata
Label says: "Expertly crafted from ripe tomatoes, garlic and chili peppers."
We say: This one has such a hard kick, it kills any other flavors.
Sodium: 420 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $6.99
No. 37 Mantia's, Roasted Garlic and Herb
Label says: "Fragrant with Italian spices and warmed by spirited conversation. Bring your friends and family together around a home-cooked meal that is delicious and simple to prepare."
We say: This one is a good inexpensive choice for garlic lovers.
Sodium: 450 mg per serving
Sugar: 8 g per serving
Where we bought it: Save-A-Lot
Price: $1.39
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 36 and No. 35
No. 36 Mario Batali, Marinara
Label says: "Crafted from imported Italian tomatoes, fresh chopped onions and fresh garlic."
We say: This sauce offers a subtle flavor, with lots of slivers of garlic.
Sodium: 480 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Dave's Supermarket
Price: $2.50
No. 35 Lucini, Spicy Tuscan Tomato
Label says: "Crafted in small batches with Lucini extra-virgin olive oil."
We say: This one is spicy for sure, almost to the point where you can't taste much else.
Sodium: 230 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $7.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 34 and No. 33
No. 34 La Vera, Arrabbiata
Label says: "Family operated. Locally produced."
We say: Spicy, but not overpowering. Reminiscent of a fine salsa.
Sodium: 690 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Dave's Supermarket
Price: $4.99
No. 33 Specially Selected, Premium Marinara
Label says: "Sweet Italian tomatoes, onion and garlic make a perfect sauce for pasta."
We say: This one is just sweet enough, though a bit on the oily side.
Sodium: 350 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Aldi's
Price: $2.49
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 32 and No. 31
No. 32 Dante, Simple Marinara
Label says: "A simple marinara made with Italian tomatoes and Soffritto combined with fresh carrots, onions and fresh celery."
We say: A very simple and basic marinara with a fresh taste. Not too sweet, though a bit short on the spices.
Sodium: 390 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $6.99
No. 31 Seggiano, Arrabbiata Chili
Label says: "Made in Sicily using sun-sweetened tomatoes and Sicilian extra virgin olive oil from an award-winning mill."
We say: Hot! Hot! Hot! Hard to taste anything but the heat.
Sodium: 310 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Whole Foods
Price: $8.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 30 and No. 29
No. 30 Stancato's, Rosa Maria
Label says: "Our most exotic sauce. Aromatic rosemary, chunky tomatoes and a romano cream that blends tradition with excitement."
We say: A solid sauce, though nothing over the top.
Sodium: 560 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $4.99
No. 29 Classico Family Favorites, Traditional
Label says: "Smooth and Rich."
We say: A fresh, homemade flavor that is good straight from the jar, and easily enhanced with your own herbs and meat.
Sodium: 420 mg per serving
Sugar: 9 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $2.39
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 28 and No. 27
No. 28 Dei Fratelli, Fire Roasted Vegetable
Label says: "Fire-roasted zucchini, red and yellow bell peppers, onions, carrots make for a deliciously flavored sauce sure to provide you with a culinary masterpiece."
We say: Very small chunks of veggies in smoky sauce.
Sodium: 400 mg per serving
Sugar: 8 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's Supermarket
Price: $2
No. 27 Priano, Four Cheese Sauce
Label says: "Inspired by Italy, no artificial flavors."
We say: This one is on the sweet side for a cheese sauce, though not enough cheese in this one. It is thin and watery.
Sodium: 450 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Aldi's
Price: $1.89
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 26 and No. 25
No. 26 Reggano, Mushroom
Label says: "A full serving of vegetables. Low in fat. A good source of fiber."
We say: This one smelled and tasted "meaty," with plenty of tiny pieces of mushrooms.
Sodium: 490 mg per serving
Sugar: 8 g per serving
Where we bought it: Aldi's
Price: $0.89
No. 25 Ragu, Chunky Sauteed Onion and Garlic
Label says: "Extra flavorful and chunky!"
We say: Not so much on the chunky side but there is plenty of sweet onion, though we didn't taste much garlic.
Sodium: 480 mg per serving
Sugar: 9 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $1.79
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 24 and No. 23
No. 24 Specially Selected, Pumpkin Chipotle
Label says: "We believe everyone should be able to enjoy unique recipes and flavor combinations every day."
We say: This is not a bad sauce if you like the heat. Sweet and smoky veggie flavor is unique, and worth sampling.
Sodium: 370 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Aldi's
Price: $2.89
No. 23 Monte Bene, Vodka
Label says: "Gluten free. No preservatives. No sugar added."
We say: Good-sized tomato chunks in a sauce that delivers pure parmesan flavor. A tad on the salty side, but still easily one of the better Vodka sauces we tried.
Sodium: 240 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $4.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 22 and No. 21
No. 22 Rao's Homemade, Arrabbiata
Label says: "This sauce is a smooth blend of vine-ripened tomatoes and four classic Italian cheeses without onions and garlic."
We say: Sweet heat! It kicks in immediately!
Sodium: 380 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $7.99
No. 21 Victoria, Vodka Sauce
Label says: "100% Italian tomatoes, imported olive oil, fresh garlic, basil and onions, Parmesan and Romano cheeses, whey, vodka, sea salt and spices."
We say: Definitely one of the better vodka sauces out there, this one is creamy and the cheese flavors are well-balanced and don't overpower the tomatoes.
Sodium: 430 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Earth Fare
Price: $7.49
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 20 and No. 19
No. 20 Simply Balanced, Organic Roasted Garlic
Label says: "No artificial colors or flavors."
We say: You can definitely appreciate the garlic in this one. A rich garlic flavor, but not overpowering. It's a little on the sweet side though.
Sodium: 540 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Target
Price: $2.09
No. 19 Guy Fieri, Traditional Old Skool
Label says: "Just like what your mama made ya with the classic flavors of ripe tomatoes, onions, basil and garlic."
We say: You can see and taste the seasonings -- though a bit heavy-handed with the garlic.
Sodium: 380 mg per serving
Sugar: 7 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's Supermarket
Price: $3.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 18 and No. 17
No. 18 Prego, Roasted Garlic Parmesan
Label says: No description of the sauce, though the label includes a 3-step recipe for chicken parmesan.
We say: True to its name, there is plenty of rich garlic flavor in this one. It has a great consistency -- not too thin and not too thick.
Sodium: 480 mg per serving
Sugar: 9 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $2.29
No. 17 Our Lady of Mt. Carmel Church, Marinara
Label says: "Our spaghetti sauce has been a favorite of our parishioners, and the Youngstown area, for years. We are happy to be able to bring it to your home."
We say: This one smells and tastes like a homemade Sunday sauce.
Sodium: 250 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's Supermarket
Price: $3.79
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 16 and No. 15
No. 16 Guy Fieri, Spicy Tomato
Label says: "Chef Guy's Spicy Tomato pasta sauce will rock your tastebuds with ripe tomato, spicy Italian-style peppers and a little tang of vinegar. Don't worry, it's not too hot, the spice is just right."
We say: This sauce will light up your taste buds, for sure! It has an extreme burn.
Sodium: 360 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Marc's Supermarket
Price: $3.99
No. 15 Sam's Choice, Italia Pasta Sauce
Label says: "Pasta sauce with cherry tomatoes and grilled vegetables."
We say: The cherry tomatoes were so big, they looked a little like meatballs. Full-on rich vegetable flavor.
Sodium: 500 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Walmart
Price: $2.98
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 14 and No. 13
No. 14 Mario Batali, Alla Vodka
Label says: "Crafted from imported Italian tomatoes, Parmigiano-Regiano cheese, fresh chopped onions, fresh garlic and crushed red pepper. No paste, puree or sugar added."
We say: This was the best vodka sauce we tasted, with plenty of cheese flavor.
Sodium: 340 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Dave's Supermarket
Price: $2.50
No. 13 Heinen's, Organic Marinara
Label says: "USDA certified organic, non-GMO verified."
We say: Good for a store-brand sauce, with plenty of chunks of tomato and garlic.
Sodium: 540 mg per serving
Sugar: 8 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $3.29
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 12 and No. 11
No. 12 Mid's, Mushroom and Roasted Garlic
Label says: "All natural. Kettle simmered for hours."
We say: A thick sauce full of mushrooms, with a mild garlic aroma and flavor.
Sodium: 700 mg per serving
Sugar: 8 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $4.49
No. 11 Fresh Thyme, Six Cheese Pasta Sauce
Label says: "Made from imported Italian Plum tomatoes. A bold blend of six cheeses and garlic. Free from artificial flavors, colors, preservatives, trans fats and gluten."
We say: A nice, thick texture, with plenty of rich and hearty cheese flavors.
Sodium: 370 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 gm per serving
Where we bought it: Fresh Thyme
Price: $5.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 10
No. 10 Stino da Napoli, Arrabbiata
Label says: "A recipe as rich as the earth of Italy, passionate with flavor. Red pepper flakes add a spicy note."
We say: This sauce carries a BIG spicy kick. It's a great sauce if you can stand the heat!
Sodium: 190 mg per serving
Sugar: 3 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $5.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 9
No. 9 Sam's Choice, Italia Puttanesca
Label says: "Pasta sauce with cherry tomatoes and olives."
We say: Packed with whole and sliced cherry tomatoes and olives, there is plenty of good, homemade flavor.
Sodium: 500 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Walmart
Price: $2.98
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 8
No. 8 Fresh Thyme, Marinara
Label says: "Made from imported Plum tomatoes, fresh onions, garlic and basil. Free from artificial flavors and colors, preservatives, trans fats, cholesterol and gluten."
We say: For a store brand, this sauce was as good as it gets. It had good consistency and a bright red color. You can see and taste the herbs.
Sodium: 400 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Fresh Thyme
Price: $5.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 7
No. 7 Newman's Own, Sockarooni
Label says: "Made with extra-virgin olive oil. No sugar added. Peppers, spices and the whole shebang."
We say: A super-thick sauce that is packed with veggies. It has a great kick, but is not so hot that it is overwhelming.
Sodium: 460 mg per serving
Sugar: 8 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $2.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 6
No. 6 Dante, Sausage Ragu
Label says: "A savory mix of sausage and spices blended with sweet herbs and tomatoes."
We say: You can see and smell the sausage and herbs as this sauce heats up. Fresh tomato taste. A solid sauce, with a slight after-burn.
Sodium: 610 mg per serving
Sugar: 4 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $6.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 5
No. 5 Mezzetta, Italian Plum Tomato
Label says: "Simple. Rich. Real."
We say: Truth in advertising here. A fresh tomato taste, though a bit on the runny side.
Sodium: 510 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $5.99
Brenda Cain, cleveland.com
No. 4
No. 4 Carfagna's, Pasta Sauce
Label says: "Original family recipe. 100% natural. 0% Trans Fats. Gluten-free."
We say: A good thick, hearty sauce. Slightly sweet but tastes like homemade.
Sodium: 540 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Lucky's Market
Price: $7.99
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 3
No. 3 Jar Goods, Classic Spicy
Label says: "Non-GMO Project verified, minimally processed, vegan, kosher."
We say: A good solid sauce that is thick and consistent -- with a kick!
Sodium: 390 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Heinen's
Price: $7.19
Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
No. 2
No. 2 Bertolli, Rustic Cut Sweet Peppers & Portobello Mushroom
Label says: "Pasta sauce with hearty vegetables, made with fresh garlic and onions."
We say: You can smell, see and taste the peppers throughout this sweet sauce. Delicious!
Sodium: 440 mg per serving
Sugar: 5 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $3.99
Brenda Cain, cleveland.com
No. 1
No. 1 Classico, Italian Sausage with Peppers and Onions
Label says: "Made with fresh onion and garlic. Gluten-free."
We say: Plenty of large chunks of peppers and onions, and sausage. This trio of flavor was fantastic. The name of the sauce is the taste you get.
Sodium: 500 mg per serving
Sugar: 6 g per serving
Where we bought it: Giant Eagle
Price: $2.39
Brenda Cain and Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com
Hungry for more? Check out more food rankings
- 34 Top selling concession items at Progressive Field
- These 25 foods caught our eyes at Progressive Field concession stands, so we ordered them and ranked them for Indians fans.
- Ranking French fries from 24 fast-food chains in Greater Cleveland; No. 1 will surprise many
- Cleveland's Best Mexican Restaurant winner is Blue Habanero! See Top 20 rankings
- Results of Cleveland's Best Brewery contest and links: What you need to know
- Cleveland's Best Sinful Desserts: Top 10 rankings, winner revealed
- Best Barbecue in Cleveland winner is Ol'Chefski's BBQ in Aurora!
- Best Burger in Cleveland winner is Gunselman's Tavern!
- Tasting and grading all 25 flavors at Graeter's Ice Cream in the new Pinecrest
- Mitchell's Ice Cream: tasting and grading all 34 flavors
- Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream: Tasting and grading 37 flavors from this national favorite
- Baskin-Robbins: Tasting and grading 20 flavors from this national favorite
- Pierre’s Ice Cream: Tasting and grading 34 flavors you can find in your grocery store
Ad Choices