Ideology in U.S. Foreign Relations
New Histories
Columbia University Press
Ideology in U.S. Foreign Relations
New Histories
Columbia University Press
Winner, 2023 Joseph Fletcher Prize for Best Edited Book in Historical International Relations, History Section, International Studies Association
Ideology drives American foreign policy in ways seen and unseen. Racialized notions of subjecthood and civilization underlay the political revolution of eighteenth-century white colonizers; neoconservatism, neoliberalism, and unilateralism propelled the post–Cold War United States to unleash catastrophe in the Middle East. Ideologies order and explain the world, project the illusion of controllable outcomes, and often explain success and failure. How does the history of U.S. foreign relations appear differently when viewed through the lens of ideology?
This book explores the ideological landscape of international relations from the colonial era to the present. Contributors examine ideologies developed to justify—or resist—white settler colonialism and free-trade imperialism, and they discuss the role of nationalism in immigration policy. The book reveals new insights on the role of ideas at the intersection of U.S. foreign and domestic policy and politics. It shows how the ideals coded as “civilization,” “freedom,” and “democracy” legitimized U.S. military interventions and enabled foreign leaders to turn American power to their benefit. The book traces the ideological struggle over competing visions of democracy and of American democracy’s place in the world and in history. It highlights sources beyond the realm of traditional diplomatic history, including nonstate actors and historically marginalized voices. Featuring the foremost specialists as well as rising stars, this book offers a foundational statement on the intellectual history of U.S. foreign policy.
Ideology drives American foreign policy in ways seen and unseen. Racialized notions of subjecthood and civilization underlay the political revolution of eighteenth-century white colonizers; neoconservatism, neoliberalism, and unilateralism propelled the post–Cold War United States to unleash catastrophe in the Middle East. Ideologies order and explain the world, project the illusion of controllable outcomes, and often explain success and failure. How does the history of U.S. foreign relations appear differently when viewed through the lens of ideology?
This book explores the ideological landscape of international relations from the colonial era to the present. Contributors examine ideologies developed to justify—or resist—white settler colonialism and free-trade imperialism, and they discuss the role of nationalism in immigration policy. The book reveals new insights on the role of ideas at the intersection of U.S. foreign and domestic policy and politics. It shows how the ideals coded as “civilization,” “freedom,” and “democracy” legitimized U.S. military interventions and enabled foreign leaders to turn American power to their benefit. The book traces the ideological struggle over competing visions of democracy and of American democracy’s place in the world and in history. It highlights sources beyond the realm of traditional diplomatic history, including nonstate actors and historically marginalized voices. Featuring the foremost specialists as well as rising stars, this book offers a foundational statement on the intellectual history of U.S. foreign policy.
A dream team of historians of U.S. foreign relations, under the masterly guidance of Christopher McKnight Nichols and David Milne, has rehabilitated the concept of ideology for a new historiographical moment. The results are indispensable: each of the parts is superb, and the whole is more than their sum. Samuel Moyn, author of Not Enough: Human Rights in an Unequal World
This is a timely and vital collection filled with brilliant insights on the often unacknowledged influence of ideology on American foreign policy. By moving far beyond a traditional framing of diplomatic history, the essays powerfully demonstrate how ideology shapes the interplay between domestic and global affairs. Keisha N. Blain, author of Until I Am Free: Fannie Lou Hamer’s Enduring Message to America
This edited collection centers ideology as a core analytical tool to explain the history and present of U.S. foreign relations. Oftentimes hard to discern or even hidden, ideologies plan and rationalize, and represent, actual policy. This is a huge undertaking and offers highly original and compelling work. Thomas Zeiler, coauthor of Globalization and the American Century
This ambitious book persuasively makes the case that historians of U.S. foreign relations/America in the world should devote more attention to ideologies and the roles ideology has played in U.S. behavior, U.S. foreign policies, and the ways Americans have understood themselves, their nation, and their role in the world. There is no book quite like this one in the field of U.S. foreign relations history. This volume will inspire new scholarship for years to come. Kelly J. Shannon, author of U.S. Foreign Policy and Muslim Women's Human Rights
This wonderfully expansive collection comes at a moment when understanding the central role ideas play in the making of American foreign relations has never been more important. It offers powerful genealogies for today’s authoritarian challenges to democratic norms, rising waves of white supremacy, and the deglobalization of the world economy. Mark Philip Bradley, editor of American Historical Review
This expansive collection shows the work of a broad diversity of ideas and voices in U.S. foreign relations history, featuring not only presidents and diplomats, but also indigenous peoples, grassroots activists, and even children. This field-expanding book will have an enduring impact on teaching and writing in foreign relations history. Mary Dudziak, author of War Time: An Idea, Its History, Its Consequences
Introduction, by Christopher McKnight Nichols and David Milne
Part I: Ideologies and the People
1. Indigenous Subjecthood and White Populism in British America, by Matthew Kruer
2. American Presidents and the Ideology of Civilization, by Benjamin A. Coates
3. Containing the Multitudes: Nationalism and U.S. Foreign Policy Ideas at the Grassroots Level, by Michaela Hoenicke-Moore
4. “Mrs. Sovereign Citizen”: Women’s International Thought and American Public Culture, 1920–1950, by Katharina Rietzler
Part II: Ideologies of Power
5. Competing Free Trade Traditions in U.S. Foreign Policy from the American Revolution to the “ American Century”, by Marc-William Palen
6. The Righteous Cause: John Quincy Adams and the Limits of American Exceptionalism, by Nicholas Guyatt
7. Antislavery and Empire: The Early Republican Party Confronts the World, by Matthew Karp
8. The Fearful Giant: National Insecurity and U.S Foreign Policy, by Andrew Preston
9. Unilateralism as Ideology, by Christopher McKnight Nichols
Part III: Ideologies of the International
10 “For Young People”: Protestant Missions, Geography, and American Youth at the End of the Nineteenth Century, by Emily Conroy-Krutz
11. Eugenia Charles, the United States, and Military Intervention in Grenada, by Imaobong Umoren
12. I Think of Myself as an International Citizen: Flemmie P. Kittrell’s Internationalist Ideology, by Brandy Thomas Wells
13. Just War as Ideology: A Militant Ecumenism of Catholics and Evangelicals, by Raymond Haberski Jr.
Part IV: Ideologies and Democracy
14. Freedom as Ideology, by Jeremi Suri
15. Roads Not Taken: The Delhi Declaration, Nelson Mandela, Václav Havel, and the Lost Futures of 1989, by Penny Von Eschen
16. Not Just Churches: American Jews, Joint Church Aid, and the Nigeria-Biafra War, by Melani McAlister
17. Contentious Designs: Ideology and U.S. Immigration Policy, by Daniel Tichenor
Part V: Ideologies of Progress
18. Capital and Immigration in the Era of the Civil War, by Jay Sexton
19. The Progressive Origins of Project RAND, by Daniel Bessner
20. Cold War Liberals, Neoconservatives, and the Rediscovery of Ideology, by Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins and Michael Franczak
21. The Galactic Vietnam: Technology, Modernization, and Empire in George Lucas’s Star Wars, by Daniel Immerwahr
22. Dual-Use Ideologies: How Science Came to Be Part of the United States’ Cold War Arsenal, by Audra J. Wolfe
Conclusion
Acknowledgments
Contributors
Index
Part I: Ideologies and the People
1. Indigenous Subjecthood and White Populism in British America, by Matthew Kruer
2. American Presidents and the Ideology of Civilization, by Benjamin A. Coates
3. Containing the Multitudes: Nationalism and U.S. Foreign Policy Ideas at the Grassroots Level, by Michaela Hoenicke-Moore
4. “Mrs. Sovereign Citizen”: Women’s International Thought and American Public Culture, 1920–1950, by Katharina Rietzler
Part II: Ideologies of Power
5. Competing Free Trade Traditions in U.S. Foreign Policy from the American Revolution to the “ American Century”, by Marc-William Palen
6. The Righteous Cause: John Quincy Adams and the Limits of American Exceptionalism, by Nicholas Guyatt
7. Antislavery and Empire: The Early Republican Party Confronts the World, by Matthew Karp
8. The Fearful Giant: National Insecurity and U.S Foreign Policy, by Andrew Preston
9. Unilateralism as Ideology, by Christopher McKnight Nichols
Part III: Ideologies of the International
10 “For Young People”: Protestant Missions, Geography, and American Youth at the End of the Nineteenth Century, by Emily Conroy-Krutz
11. Eugenia Charles, the United States, and Military Intervention in Grenada, by Imaobong Umoren
12. I Think of Myself as an International Citizen: Flemmie P. Kittrell’s Internationalist Ideology, by Brandy Thomas Wells
13. Just War as Ideology: A Militant Ecumenism of Catholics and Evangelicals, by Raymond Haberski Jr.
Part IV: Ideologies and Democracy
14. Freedom as Ideology, by Jeremi Suri
15. Roads Not Taken: The Delhi Declaration, Nelson Mandela, Václav Havel, and the Lost Futures of 1989, by Penny Von Eschen
16. Not Just Churches: American Jews, Joint Church Aid, and the Nigeria-Biafra War, by Melani McAlister
17. Contentious Designs: Ideology and U.S. Immigration Policy, by Daniel Tichenor
Part V: Ideologies of Progress
18. Capital and Immigration in the Era of the Civil War, by Jay Sexton
19. The Progressive Origins of Project RAND, by Daniel Bessner
20. Cold War Liberals, Neoconservatives, and the Rediscovery of Ideology, by Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins and Michael Franczak
21. The Galactic Vietnam: Technology, Modernization, and Empire in George Lucas’s Star Wars, by Daniel Immerwahr
22. Dual-Use Ideologies: How Science Came to Be Part of the United States’ Cold War Arsenal, by Audra J. Wolfe
Conclusion
Acknowledgments
Contributors
Index
Winner, 2023 Joseph Fletcher Prize for Best Edited Book in Historical International Relations, History Section, International Studies Association